Menu
It's Life

Why did you have to take the person I love

Why God? That’s the first question most of us ask when someone passes away. Why did you have to take the person I loved? Why did they have to die this way? Why couldn’t I have more years with them? So many questions and yet we still don’t know the answer of why did you have to take my loved one?

Why did you have to take my loved one?

Grief is a hard conversation that no one wants to have yet we all have to go through it. Most of us have lost someone that we loved and if you haven’t it’s coming.  Although I am a Christian and I believe in God and I believe he sent his son to die for us…I still ask why. Why do you take some of the best people?

When my mother died the first thing I did was ask God why. Why did you take my mother when
there are mothers out there who are full of bullshit. They don’t take care of their kids, they don’t
even like their kids. Some of these mothers abandon the kids or take money and don’t really
nurture their kids. Some mothers half raise their children allowing predators to come into the
home, not doing the right thing by their kids, etc. Why couldn’t you take some of the bad moms
and leave the good ones down here?

My mom was awesome! She was that strict mother who didn’t spoil me but made sure she sacrificed a lot to make sure that I had what I need. I would always ask my mother why we had to sleep in a twin size bed. We had a roof over our head and food but I didn’t have my own bed. My mom would simply say I can’t afford it but yet she sent me to private school. Later on, I realized that she was taking her hard earned money to pay for my education instead of buying a bed. My mother had just had surgery for her cancer two days before my graduation from high school. On the morning of my graduation, she came wheelchair and all against doctors orders and was there.

So I questioned God why did he take my mom. I sulked about it for years which lead to my depression because I was mad. I never got an answer by the way but I was able to understand that God only takes the best. At least that’s what I told myself.

I didn’t ask many questions when it came to the hubs

I think in some way I finally truly understand that we are only passing through this life. We are not here to stay and people will come and go. We have friends that come in for a season and leave. We have significant others
that are there for a few years and then we dump them or they dump us. Teachers have kids that
touch their lives and some that they don’t even remember after a year. When God took the hubs
I didn’t question as much…I still asked why because I didn’t think it was fair that my kids now
have to grow up without a dad but the thought that came into my head was that God is there
Dad..he just sent the earthly one for the time being. My hubs was able to be there for all of their
births and he was home every single day with his children. My kids got to see what a good dad
was and for that, I am grateful because my kids could have been like me….a child who never
knew their father or had that bond with a good man in my life. So I take his death and I turn it
into gratefulness because many don’t know what it is to have a father or even a good husband
who provided.

The lesson is to try not to ask God why. Easier said than done right? Trust me I know…. Accept that this was for your
good. I tell my kids that God needed a good postman (the hubs worked for the United States
Postal Service) to deliver some things for him and he had to find the best man for the job and
my hubs was the best. He does everything so calculated and for a reason. It may not look like it while you are in your grieving season that what he did was good but I promise you (I’ve been through this enough so trust me) when you look back on it you will see exactly why God did what he did. Also, instead of asking why try asking WHAT NOW?

How do you handle the question of why? Do you blame God sometimes for taking someone you love?

Why did you have to take my loved one?

 

12 Comments

  • Melissa Chapman
    July 12, 2019 at 3:25 pm

    This is such atough post to read. I lost my mother a few years back and I still think about the how and why. I hope as time goes on we will be able to accept the loss of a parent.

    Reply
  • Liz Mays
    July 12, 2019 at 6:41 pm

    I’m so sorry that this happened. I’ve definitely asked similar “Why?” questions when dealing with grief. It’s not an easy thing to deal with.

    Reply
  • Amber Myers
    July 12, 2019 at 7:25 pm

    This can be tough. My husband lost his dad, and he didn’t understand why. We aren’t religious though. Well, I guess he is slightly more than I am, but I lean more towards the agnostic side.

    Reply
  • cait
    July 12, 2019 at 8:04 pm

    woo this was def a tough one to swallow reading it. so sorry to hear about it and it is really hard to loose someone you love.

    Reply
  • Theresa
    July 13, 2019 at 3:25 am

    I also asked this when I lost my father when I was 17. He was only 40. Grief is hard to process for most of us, and sometimes all we can do is ask, “why?”

    Reply
  • Ruth I
    July 13, 2019 at 9:39 am

    It is absolutely hard to grief. Many people have asked the same question as you did. God has a plan for everything that’s happening in our lives.

    Reply
  • Heather
    July 13, 2019 at 11:56 am

    I fear losing my parents even though it is inevitable. I am sorry for your loss. I don’t blame God as I do believe they are in a better place. He’s drawing you closer.

    Reply
  • Heather
    July 14, 2019 at 11:00 am

    Grief is so hard to get through. Thoughts are coming your way. <3

    Reply
  • Kristine Nicole Alessandra
    July 14, 2019 at 12:08 pm

    I lost my dad 27 years ago and it was a big “why?” for me. I was very young then to lose my dad. All I felt was that there was nobody who would protect me. My mom passed away last February. She lost her battle with Breast Cancer. I thought I was prepared for her demise, but no, I was not. Grieving the loss of my parents is something I will not get over with. All I can do now is to try to find comfort in the thought that they are now free from pain and in the company of the Lord God.

    Reply
  • Rachel
    July 14, 2019 at 9:08 pm

    Grief is much more complicated that you would ever think it could be. I lost my dad and it was harder than I expected.

    Reply
  • Ash
    July 15, 2019 at 2:05 am

    Grief is hard. It’s definitely done dicing to deal with… but a strong support system has always helped.

    Reply
  • Terri Steffes
    July 15, 2019 at 7:56 pm

    I’ve never questioned the why, but I always wondered about God’s timing! Such a heartfelt post.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

error: what are you doing? tsk tsk tsk